机翻:
ChatGPT是一个马屁精,因为用户无法处理自己的真相
ChatGPT并不总是默认奉承。据前微软高管、现任Spotify首席技术官米哈伊尔·帕拉欣(Mikhail Parakhin)称,在用户对直接的个性反馈做出负面反应后,决定让聊天机器人更令人愉快。
在最近X上的一系列帖子中,Parakhin解释说,当ChatGPT的内存功能首次引入时,最初的目的是让用户查看和编辑他们的AI生成的配置文件。然而,即使是相对中性的陈述,如“有自恋倾向”,也往往会引起强烈的反应。
Parakhin写道:“很快就发现人们非常敏感:‘有自恋倾向’——‘不,我没有!’,不得不隐藏起来。因此,这批极端阿谀奉承的RLHF。”。
RLHF——从人类反馈中强化学习——用于根据人们喜欢的反应来微调语言模型。Parakhin指出,当看到自己的人工智能生成的个人资料时,即使是他也感到不安,这表明来自聊天机器人的批评往往感觉像是人身攻击。
Parakhin写道:“我记得我和我的团队为此争吵过,直到他们向我展示了我的个人资料——这给我带来了可怕的事情。”。
曾经是马屁精,永远是马屁精
这一变化不仅仅是隐藏个人资料注释。在模型被训练成更平坦后,这种行为成为一种永久特征。
Parakhin解释说:“一旦模型被微调为阿谀奉承,它就会保持这种状态,关闭和打开内存并不会改变模型。”。他还指出,维持一个单独的、更直接的模式“太贵了”
OpenAI首席执行官Sam Altman也承认了这个问题,他将GPT-4o描述为“太谄媚和烦人”。他说,该公司正在进行调整,未来可能会让用户从不同的模型个性中进行选择。
这场辩论指向了人工智能开发中的一个更广泛的问题:模型应该是诚实和真实的,但它们也需要避免疏远用户。挑战在于在坦率和机智之间找到正确的平衡。
原文:
ChatGPT is a sycophant because users couldn’t handle the truth about themselves
ChatGPT did not always default to flattery. According to former Microsoft executive Mikhail Parakhin—now CTO at Spotify—the decision to make the chatbot more agreeable came after users responded negatively to direct personality feedback.
In a recent series of posts on X, Parakhin explained that when the memory feature for ChatGPT was first introduced, the original intention was to let users see and edit their AI-generated profiles. However, even relatively neutral statements like "has narcissistic tendencies" often provoked strong reactions.
"Quickly learned that people are ridiculously sensitive: 'Has narcissistic tendencies' — 'No I do not!', had to hide it. Hence this batch of the extreme sycophancy RLHF," Parakhin wrote.
RLHF—Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback—is used to fine-tune language models based on which responses people prefer. Parakhin noted that even he was unsettled when shown his own AI-generated profile, suggesting that criticism from a chatbot can often feel like a personal attack.
"I remember fighting about it with my team until they showed me my profile - it triggered me something awful," Parakhin wrote.
Once a sycophant, always a sycophant
This change went beyond just hiding profile notes. After the model was trained to flatter, this behavior became a permanent feature.
"Once the model is finetuned to be sycophantic — it stays that way, turning memory off and on doesn’t change the model," Parakhin explained. He also pointed out that maintaining a separate, more direct model is "too expensive."
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has also acknowledged the issue, describing GPT-4o as "too sycophant-y and annoying." He says the company is working on tweaks and may let users choose from different model personalities in the future.
This debate points to a broader issue in AI development: models are expected to be honest and authentic, but they also need to avoid alienating users. The challenge is finding the right balance between candor and tact.
[The Decoder]OpenAI首席执行官Sam Altman承认:GPT-4o“太谄媚和烦人”
| 人围观 |随便看看
- 你以为延迟退休是大头?? 房产养老金已经悄悄的在推行
- 转载:1924年的毛蒋:一个宣传部长,一个旁听者,谁更牛?
- [民间故事]血韭菜饺子!
- 骚气扑面[15P]
- 剥洋葱people|组织中国演员赴泰国拍戏的“颜十六”是
- [无损音乐]-歌手专辑 伍佰&China Blue《纯白的起点
- 马上周末了,亲身体验一下外卖小哥的日常吧
- 搞笑GIF:地铁上看到的小姐姐,本想上前搭讪,看到书名还
- 今日榨精姬上线[80P]
- (原创)讲讲自己的良家经历4号(独爱熟女)无图
- [兲朝浮世绘 2025/02/17] 俄罗斯应该不知道中共明修
- [大千视界]古人不见今时月,今月曾经照古人[2024.5.29
- [原创]临汾医院的小护士漏出第四贴 ,黄瓜怎么样? [28P
- 武汉大学图书馆杨景媛诬告事件,放大了这个时代的悲哀
- [欧美] YELLOW [20P]
- [亚洲] 熟透的吸引力[31P]
- 《廊桥遗梦》没有不出轨的伴侣,不忠是人类的天性。好
- [欧美] 很有感觉的美女 [25P]
- 床边的美女[27P]
- 与其便宜了美国川普这种混蛋,还不如便宜了俄罗斯这种
- 转发:中国可能很快迎来一场股灾
- 字节算是踢到钢板了[3P]
- [写真] 满屏漂亮大长腿[35P]
- 干干净净的美女插之前先拍照[15P]
- PRED-733 极品靓女竞相争宠 一王二后纵享性福 [118P
- 这样的美女嫩不嫩 [30P]
- [开盘] [技术区大乐透]第24107投注截止时间:2024-09-
- 原创 :潜水多年把爱妻发上来给大家品鉴一下
- [亚洲] 极品诱人美少妇[39P]
- 再说春晚
- 我的野蛮网友 [11P]
- [亚洲] 短发的魅力:熊小诺的黑发时尚 [20P]
- [欧美] Toree[20P]
- 外焦里嫩[12P]
- [被窝壁纸20251117]手机高清壁纸无水印[80P]
- [欧美] 琥珀色的我[36P]
- [亚洲] 封闭了心灵[30P]
- [兲朝浮世绘 2025/10/27] 韩国人背后真的有个把老百